BundleBear

2024 Year in Review

ERC-4337 smart accounts empower developers to deliver great onchain user experiences. In 2024, ERC-4337 adoption grew more than tenfold and impacted a range of categories, from gaming to decentralised social apps.

The BundleBear 2024 Year in Review aims to provide a data-driven perspective on the major patterns and trends in the ERC-4337 ecosystem.

All insights are based on ERC-4337 activity on Base, Polygon, Optimism, Arbitrum, Linea, Arbitrum Nova, Celo, Avalanche, BSC and Ethereum.

User Activity

103M+ User Operations were made in 2024

When you use an ERC-4337 account, you submit User Operations (UserOps) instead of transactions. These UserOps get grouped into bundle transactions that are executed onchain by Bundlers.

In 2024, 103M UserOps were executed. That's more than 10X the number of UserOps made in 2023 (8.3M).

The number of monthly UserOps peaked at 18.4M in August, then steadily declined to 9.8M in December.

Monthly UserOps

21.8M accounts made a UserOp in 2023. But only 4.3M accounts made more than one UserOp.

The majority of accounts that were active in 2024 only transacted once. People farming sign-up rewards and similar token incentive schemes drove this “single-use” behaviour. Only a few apps inspired “repeat use” behaviour, convincing users to transact more than once.

Monthly active repeat-use accounts hit a high of 1M in October. Monthly active single-use accounts peaked earlier in the year in July.

Monthly Active Accounts

Top 10 most used protocols

Here are the protocols that ERC-4337 accounts used the most this year:

Project
Piggybox
12606597
12614726
Cyberconnect
1702879
1718831
Blocklords
1455201
25598209
Super Champs
665893
3384916
Yellow Network
648532
3399860
Burn Address
628866
687666
OpenSocial
568656
11375699
ManagedAccountFactory Thirdweb
555098
9702287
Anichess Orb Token Claim
457949
6802711
River
299723
632289

Here is what the leaderboard looks like if we exclude the activity of single-use accounts:

Project
Blocklords
897743
25040394
OpenSocial
545995
11353038
Anichess Orb Token Claim
389405
6734167
Yellow Network
359056
3110384
Super Champs
303554
3022577
River
269280
601846
Somon Badge
172042
658841
KIP
168804
4056836
Ducklings
146098
212259
xFANTV
146003
371268

Protocols like Piggybox and Cyberconnect attracted a lot of single-use account activity in 2024. They sit at the top of the overall leaderboard. But fall when we filter out single-use accounts they fall out the top 5. Piggybox is an NFT you get when you sign up for EARN'M, along with a lottery box that might contain EARNM token. Cyberconnect is a social app that had a heavily farmed airdrop. It's easy to see why protocols like these, which reward users even if they only transact once, struggle to retain them.

Trends in Repeat-use Accounts Activity

Anichess, a chess game where you can earn NFTs, was the most popular app amongst repeat-use accounts in Q1.

In Q2, Alfafrens, a social app where users can stake ALFA to earn DEGEN, briefly took the top spot before being overtaken by Blocklords, a strategy game with onchain elements.

Blocklords usage blew up in Q3 and drove a 5X+ increase in monthly active repeat-use accounts. Then, a social app called OpenSocial took most of the market share. By the end of the year, a mobile game called SuperChamps had flipped OpenSocial for first place.

Project Share of UserOps (Repeat-use Accounts)

* Excluding calls related to factory setup

55% of Repeat-use accounts transacted on Base

Base was the second largest chain by smart account usage overall, with 3.7M accounts transacting in 2024. Polygon was first with 16.6M.

But Base had the most repeat-use accounts. 2.4M accounts made more than one UserOp on Base in 2024.

Chain Share of Monthly Active Repeat-use Accounts

Bundler Performance

59M bundle transactions were made in 2024

The role of a Bundler is to package UserOps into bundle transactions. The number of monthly bundle transactions consistently increased month-over-month throughout the year.

Monthly Bundle Transactions

Top 5 Bundlers

Here are the Bundlers who had the most activity in 2024

Bundler
coinbase
30257644
9459333
$153,949.61
alchemy
25664813
10777277
$80,271.24
pimlico
23171379
13961586
$97,843.64
biconomy
16599136
15151435
$130,091.58
particle
1979591
1867827
$302,336.72
Note: Onchain revenue is the difference between UserOp fees paid to the Bundler and the gas fees the Bundler pays to make transactions. This is not the main revenue source for most Bundlers; they charge developers offchain subscription fees or theyre subsidized by larger orgs.

24% of the bundles made in 2024 contained more than one UserOp

When bundles contain multiple UserOps, smart account users save money because the cost of the bundle transaction is shared between all the UserOps. Bundlers also benefit because they spend less by making fewer transactions while charging the same gas premium on every UserOp. But there isn't always enough UserOp volume to fill bundles with multiple UserOps.

In 2024, the monthly percentage of bundle transactions with multiple UserOps grew from 2.5% in January to a peak of 49% in August, then fell to 23% at the end of the year. This is an improvement from 2023 when most months didn't exceed 10%.

Monthly % of Multi-UserOp Bundles

Bundler Market Share

From January to May, Biconomy was the top Bundler by UserOps executed. This is because they were the exclusive Bundler for apps like Anichess and Alfafrens, which peaked in usage around that time.

Alchemy briefly took the #1 spot in June, thanks to UserOp flow from Piggybox. Then Coinbase’s market share surged in July because Blocklords used their bundler. Alchemy retook the top spot in September and October because of Opensocial.

Pimlico jumped to first place for the last two months of the year because they bundled for apps on Thirdweb’s developer SDK.

Bundler Share of UserOps

Paymaster Usage

Apps and Users have spent more than $3.4M on UserOp fees through Paymasters

Paymaster contracts allow applications to set up custom gas fee policies for their users.

Apps can let users pay for gas using ERC-20 tokens or they can cover the gas fees on behalf of their users.

Monthly Paymaster Volume

Top 5 Paymasters

Here are the Paymasters who had the most spending this year:

Paymaster
biconomy
14519423
$1,012,818.02
pimlico
18561350
$761,489.12
stackup
215854
$514,090.49
coinbase
21578423
$358,269.46
alchemy
19402438
$253,356.41

87% of all UserOps were paid for using a Paymaster

Most of the UserOps made in 2024 were paid for using a paymaster. This means that either the app/wallet/L2 subsidized the fees or user paid their fees using an ERC20 token.

Factory Insights

58% of accounts were deployed using Alchemy's factory contracts

Most ERC-4337 accounts are created using a factory contract. A factory is a smart contract that generates other smart contracts. In 2024, 58% of all new accounts were deployed using the Alchemy LightAccount factory.

Monthly Accounts Deployed

38% of the accounts that got multiple uses were deployed with the SimpleAccount Factory

SimpleAccount is a factory that was developed by the Ethereum Foundation. Blocklords used this factory to deploy their accounts and that pushed it to the top spot on the repeat-use account leaderboard.

Top 5 Factories by Repeat-use Accounts Deployed
Account Deployer
simpleaccount
1580855
biconomy
858030
zerodev_kernel
566222
thirdweb_managedaccount
174005
alchemy_modularaccount
69390